Nashville

After having searched all over North America, Phil Miller returns home to Tucson and tries to make a life for himself, convinced that he’s The Last Man on Earth. Then, a new survivor, Carol Pilbasian, emerges.

While Carol puts lots of thought and care into her wedding, Phil does his best to pretend like it is not happening.

Phil and Carol are shocked to find Melissa, another survivor, just after Phil reluctantly agreed to marry Carol.

Phil continues to try and find a morally sound method to romantically pursue Melissa, only to have his schemes continually backfire.

After the arrival of the sweet-hearted Todd, Phil attempts to keep him away from Melissa while Carol tries to nudge them closer.

Todd and Melissa drive Phil crazy with their constant love-making and cutesy behavior. Meanwhile, the community comes together and votes to force Phil to clean his toilet pool.

Despite Carol nagging him, Todd’s happiness, and Melissa’s complete disinterest, Phil makes a discovery that is going to change the game. Literally.

With Carol now living in Phil’s house and reorganizing his entire life, he asks God for a “do-over” on his entire life, and unfortunately, he gets one.

Once Phil fails to convince everyone that his running off with Gail and Erica was a prank, he chooses a much different and entirely unexpected strategy.

Phil attempts to alter his "Alive in Tucson" signs so no more men will show up, but he ends up marooned on one of his billboards with no one to help.

With the arrival of New Phil Miller, a handsome handyman of few words, Old Phil starts to lose all of the things he holds dear.

Tandy realizes that he is super-jealous of New Phil's relationship with Carol, so he decides he must win her back.