the last season of SG-1 was kind of crappy.
I lost interest in SGA somewhere after the start of season 2this is pretty decent. I am not yet trying to run home to see it. this may be hulu's fault though.
fpr the BSG comparisons I don't see it but I decided I wasn't watching that when I realized they had put starbuck and apollo as lovers.... just couldn't go there.
so this isn't as good as original SG1 is about as good as Atlantis
but absolutely better than FARGATE. (nothing personal to Claudia and Ben but they never should have been on another sci-fi show together for long term just couldn't put them in the SG storyline)   See 7 other replies

i agree about the style it was shot in all shows with style just annoy me cause something just doesn't seem right about them!   See 7 other replies

This whole series is an experiment in... television series. Seriously, they took social rejects who are the exact opposites of future-heroes with great potential and put them all in a TV series. How can that make a good drama series? We're supposed to be intrigued by how much these losers can mess up and try to patch things with each other. I'm trying to like this series, believe me. It's getting hard, though. I want it to get good and become really cool. I do think the writers can find ways for the characters to improve and show their hidden potential. I hope they take the story that direction.   See 7 other replies

"You have a bunch of people who are the POLAR opposites of the heroes we're used to from the first two series...."
Not really. If the characters were polar opposites, they would be villains or anti-heroes. They would have nothing noble or admirable about them.
Characters like Young, Rush and Greer, while flawed, also have strong admirable qualities.And on the other hand previous SG characters where not 100% hero , especially when the character was introduced. O'Neill was too much shoot and ask questions later. McKay was a really selfish coward.Sure SG1 and SGA are different in tone from SGU, but not nearly as different as TS and other in different posts are trying to claim.   See 7 other replies

couldn't agree more, you've just summed it all up right there   See 7 other replies