Mainlander or Islander? is the criteria here. Daniel MacIver both wrote and directed this gem--a feat of creativity all its own; and I am dumbfounded by so many reviews who either absolutely hate it or really love it. I loved it for it's slice-of-life subtlety with poignant characterizations that were so realistic and understated, even though sometimes unbelievable in their quirkyness. I, too, do not feel it should be labeled a comedy, even though some ridiculous frenetic action was imbued into the Sandra Oh character which did indeed make you laugh. The subplots were what made this film tick, and the actors were all superb. So I guess it's a matter of who likes what. Guess I'm an islander.