Years ago, when my children were young, I rented this movie and immediately turned it off as the first Christmas morning scene unfolded. "Argh," I said to myself, "No one wants to see a film about a man cheating on his wife and ruining his family." Decades later, I re-visited this film one evening and found myself completely riveted by it.
The film is "thin" and one needs to watch it more than once to fill in the blanks. It appears the producer and director were attempting a modern version of a 40"s-50's romance film, but wanted to give it an "edgier" and more realistic story line. Many will find it disconcerting that the premise hangs on the dissolution of two unhappy marriages in order for the central characters to make space for what seems to be their own selfish happiness, but after hanging on to a failing marriage for over 25 years, I found myself profoundly understanding the underlying dynamics in the film.
The complex emotions that undulate throughout this film are beautifully depicted in the facial expressions, controlled tempo of words and breath of both actors, but Meryl does it all a touch better than her counterpart. Watching their eyes move back and forth caused me to enter into the story of two people struggling to hold back an attraction that lures them closer and closer to a flame they both know will burn them.
While we are meagerly exposed to it, we get the sense that the loneliness they suffer in their marriages compels them forward into a companionship that both heals and cuts.They can hardly bear the ache within their marriages, but neither can they bear the ache of tearing all that they have apart, and then again, neither can they bear the ache of being apart from each other.
In the end, they are given a chance to "go back," but neither can. The final scenes are well, Hollywood trite, but given that, both DeNiro and Streep act so believably in the confines of the predictable romance happy ending script, one simply forgives the contrivance. As they gaze into each other's eyes, one sighs and closes the book. It was a fairy tale after all.
I will most likely watch it again, maybe a few times, maybe more.