I could kinda see this show being cancelled by Foxx coming, 'cause although the premise was a little hokey, the show had some good qualities and characteers and that seems to be Foxx's M.O. The uncool part is that there is no closure. You would think a person that supposedly was a recovering alcholic would have practiced at least some of the principles of A.A. I could see being a male chauvinist jerk in his past but once he recovered what was it in the sixties he would have had forty years to work on his honesty and character which was definetly lacking. The ending was just stupid and didn't really follow the story line not to mention most people that live to be 400 years old would have probable left NY and seen the country a little, hey maybe even the world. The show really had some interesting possibilities however when he met the ONE so early you new it was doomed to be cancelled, hell where do go from there. i was kinda hoping as he was walking away in the middle of the street that he would have been hit by a bus and run over . . . . . now that would have been a good ending and we all could of had some closure!

The immortal indian potion was kind of dumb; too dumb for such a good show. Ok does anyone else out there feel that sexual tension between John and the lieutenant? They were totally about to heat up the show! As for Fox's habit of canceling great shows like New Amsterdam, Journeyman, and Terminator:TSCC to name a few, the executives only care about one thing the almighty dollar and they replace a low rated show with a bubblegum reality faster than you can say Firefly! Thanks for not killing Dollhouse and Fringe.....yet!

This show was a good show that deserved to last longer than 8 episodes. And, they should have had a chance to complete the show before it was cancelled. I got into the show and the characters and now we will never know who his soulmate was. But, my money is on Eva (his partner).

The premise was great and definitely ripe for good storytelling. Still, I don't feel the writers truly hit the mark. I never for one minute (throughout all of the episodes) believed that Amsterdam was really in love with the Dr. There was more chemistry between him and his partner and him and the chief then there was between him and the Dr. Plus we never got a real sense of Amsterdam's growth as a person. Why tell his story in this moment as opposed to any other? There just didn't seem to be a good enough reason that made this story (of all his stories) the most relevant...the one on which to focus. Loved the idea and it would have been nice to have a resolve to the series but I see why it was canceled.

Exceptional. Sorry to see it left at the point it was....unfinished.