After reading some of the other reviews posted on this page, I can see where Picket Fences could come off as convoluted or stupid. I think they forget that Picket Fences was pure satire in the strickest sense of the word. Rome, Wisconsin is almost like the Land Of Oz of the 1990's...completely smothered in fantasy, while maintaining a real feel.
But the two main elements of Picket Fences that I fell in love with were the Emmy winning performances by the late Ray Walston as Judge Henry Bone and Fyvish Finkle as Attorney Joseph Wambaugh. I love Judge Bone's favorite line, "Get out!", and you never knew what was going to come out of the mouth of Attorney Wambaugh...simply hilarious!
I will concede however, that by the middle of season 2, the stories were getting extremely contrived and hard to watch. I'm not sure what happened to make the show suddenly lose it's edge, but it's like it happened overnight.
So, if you really want to enjoy Picket Fences, just watch the first season and a half...and then FREEZE!!!! DROP THE REMOTE, AND BACK AWAY FROM THE TELEVISION.... SLOWLY!!!!
Welcome to Rome, Wisconsin! :-)